
At Thanksgiving dinner, dad read me a two-page letter: “you will never set foot on grandpa’s tree farm again”; all of this simply because i refused to let my sister sell it; she raised her phone to record me, expecting me to cry; i folded the letter, put it in my pocket, and told him, “deal, neither will you”; the next morning…
“You will never set foot on Grandpa’s Christmas tree farm again.”
My father read those words aloud at Thanksgiving dinner, standing at the head of the table with a two-page letter in his hands. He had typed it at home, printed it at the library, and folded it neatly into his shirt pocket long before any of us sat down to eat. This wasn’t something he’d said in the heat of an argument. He had planned every word, right down to the moment he would deliver it.
My younger sister, Tabitha, sat directly across from me, holding her phone sideways and recording the whole thing. She wasn’t even pretending to be discreet. She had the camera trained on my face, waiting for the moment I would finally break down and cry.
My wife, April, was already on her feet by the time Dad tapped his iced tea glass with a fork and announced that the children ought to go watch television. She knew that tone of voice. She had heard it enough times over the years to recognize when my father was about to make a scene.
Instead of sending our kids into the living room, she took our nine-year-old daughter, May, and our six-year-old son, Jude, outside to the car. Before Dad reached the second sentence, Tabitha swung her phone toward them as they left. I put my hand flat in front of the lens.
“Not them,” I told her.
She turned the camera back toward me, apparently satisfied that she still had the person she wanted.
Then Dad read the entire letter.
Two pages explaining how I had supposedly lived off his father for six years, how I had turned his own father against him, and how, as of that day, he had only one child left. He accused me of refusing to let my sister sell Grandpa’s farm, and he declared that because of my behavior, I would never be allowed on that land again.
When he finished, he held the letter across the sweet potato casserole as though he were serving me a legal summons.
I took it from him, folded it in half, then folded it in half again. I slipped it into the inside pocket of my coat and looked him straight in the eyes.
“Deal,” I said. “Neither will you.”
Dad narrowed his eyes. “What’s that supposed to mean?”
“It means exactly what it says, Dad. You wrote it.”
I stood, thanked my mother for dinner, and walked outside to the car, where my six-year-old son was waiting to ask whether Grandpa was angry with Daddy.
There was something nobody at that table had bothered to find out before deciding they could throw me off the land I’d worked for most of my life.
The Christmas tree farm my father had just banned me from entering no longer belonged to Grandpa. It didn’t belong to my father, either.
It hadn’t belonged to anyone but me since February.
And the following morning, when Dad and Tabitha drove up my driveway with a man who was prepared to buy the property, I was standing there with Grandpa’s recorded deed in one coat pocket and Dad’s letter in the other.
My name is Mike. I’m forty-one years old, and I grow Christmas trees on a hillside just outside West Jefferson, North Carolina.
The farm is twenty-two acres of Fraser firs, with a barn that houses a tree baler and shaker, an old farmhouse my grandfather built in 1968, and a gravel parking lot that can hold about sixty cars, provided everybody parks with a little common sense. Most people don’t, especially on opening weekend, but we’ve learned to work around that.
My grandfather’s name was Ulten. He planted his first Fraser firs on that hillside when my father was still a little boy, and he worked those rows until his knees finally told him he couldn’t do it anymore.
Grandma Belma ran the cash register and made Christmas wreaths. She had a way of arranging fresh fir branches that made even the simplest wreath look like something special. She kept doing it until she passed away when I was in high school.
After that, it was just Grandpa. And every summer, it was Grandpa and me.
I spent practically every summer of my childhood up on that hill, learning how to plant, prune, mow, and recognize a healthy tree before it was tall enough to reach my knees. Grandpa taught me how to sharpen a saw, how to read the weather by looking at the clouds coming across the mountains, and how to keep working when the job wasn’t particularly pleasant.
My father, Reggie, grew up on that same hillside, but he left the week he turned eighteen. He went down the mountain to Hickory, found a job in a furniture warehouse, and worked there for more than thirty years.
Whenever somebody asked why he’d left, he said he couldn’t stand the cold.
Grandpa had a different explanation. He always said my father left because trimming Christmas trees in July was hot, sticky work, and the cold never had a thing to do with it.
Whatever the real reason, Dad almost never came back.
There was one exception.
Every year, on the Saturday after Thanksgiving, he would drive up with Mom and Tabitha. He’d stroll through the rows as though he were browsing through a department store, point to the best tree on the entire hillside, and announce, “That one.”
Grandpa would cut it, shake the loose needles off, run it through the baler, and tie it onto the roof of Dad’s car.
Then Dad would drive back down the mountain without paying a dime or asking whether anyone needed a hand with the work.
Grandpa never charged him. He would simply stand there watching the car disappear around the bend and say, “Well, he picked himself a good one.”
Tabitha is three years younger than I am. She’s thirty-eight now, divorced, and works selling cell phone plans at a kiosk in a shopping mall in Hickory.
She visited the farm about as often as Dad did. Whenever she came, she made sure to take a picture of herself standing in front of the rows of trees. Then she’d post it online with a caption about being back at our family farm.
Grandpa had an old flip phone and never saw those pictures. I always figured that was probably for the best. He was the one out there in the summer heat making sure those trees survived, while my sister enjoyed telling people she had a beautiful mountain property in the family.
For a while, I had my own life down at the foot of the mountain.
I drove a delivery route for a feed mill in Boone for twelve years. It was steady work, and I didn’t mind it. I knew the roads, the farmers, and the rhythm of the seasons. I met April, who remains the most practical human being I have ever known, and we built a life together.
May came along first, and then Jude.
Every Thanksgiving weekend, I took time off from my job and headed up the mountain to help Grandpa through the opening week of Christmas tree season. By then, his knees were getting bad, and there was no way he could handle the crowds, cutting, shaking, baling, and loading by himself.
Nobody else was going to show up to help him. We both knew that without having to say it.
Six years ago, Grandpa called me one afternoon in January. He was eighty years old.
“Come up Sunday,” he said. “Bring April. Don’t bring the kids. They’ll eat all my cookies.”
That was his way of letting me know he wanted to discuss something serious without having little hands reaching across the kitchen table.
April and I went up that Sunday and sat across from him at the red kitchen table in his farmhouse. It’s the same table that still sits in my kitchen today, with the same worn places in the finish where Grandpa rested his elbows.
He slid a sheet of notebook paper toward me. There were numbers written on it in pencil, arranged in careful columns.
“My knees are done,” he said. “I can’t get up and down those rows anymore. I’m not selling to a stranger, and I’m not giving it away, either.”
April looked at him. “Why not give it away?”
That was April. She didn’t waste time circling around the practical question.
Grandpa pointed his pencil at me.
“Because then he’d never feel like it was his. A man ought to pay for his own land, or he’ll spend the rest of his life feeling like he’s borrowing it.”
He’d worked out a price.
It was a family price, far below what the property could have brought from someone interested in building vacation cabins on the hillside. The views alone would have made the land attractive to a developer.
I told him that. I didn’t want him selling me something worth so much more without fully understanding what he was doing.
He looked at me as though I’d missed the entire point.
“I know exactly what somebody building cabins would pay for this hill,” he said. “That’s why I didn’t call one of them.”
The arrangement was straightforward. I’d pay him $1,400 a month for six years. When the final payment cleared, the farm would belong to me.
April flipped the notebook paper over and did the arithmetic in about four seconds.
“That’s $100,800,” she said.
“That’s right,” Grandpa answered. “And he’ll earn every penny of it the same way I did.”
The following week, he took us to Jefferson to see his attorney, Mr. Thurman Ensley. Mr. Ensley was about Grandpa’s age and had been handling his legal affairs since the 1970s.
He drew up a proper contract for the sale of the property.
Before Grandpa signed anything, Mr. Ensley asked him a long series of questions. He wanted to be certain Grandpa understood the price, the payment schedule, and exactly what he was agreeing to transfer.
I sat outside in the hallway while the two of them discussed it.
When they finally came out, Mr. Ensley shook my hand.
“Your grandfather knows exactly what he’s doing,” he told me. “I put that in my file, too, in case anybody ever decides to question it.”
At the time, I thought that was an odd thing to say.
I couldn’t imagine anyone in our family questioning a deal Grandpa had made with his own money and his own property.
I was wrong about that.
I turned in my notice at the feed mill. April and I sold our little house in Boone, packed up everything we owned, and moved into the farmhouse on the hill.
Grandpa moved to a single-story house in town near his church. There were no stairs to climb, no steep rows of trees to walk, and no reason for him to spend another July afternoon covered in sweat and fir sap.
He told me it was the first house he’d ever lived in where he couldn’t look out a window and see half a dozen jobs waiting to be done.
He said he wasn’t entirely sure he liked that.
I told my family about the arrangement at Easter that year.
We were having dinner at Mom and Dad’s house in Hickory. I didn’t make a big announcement. I simply explained that I was buying the Christmas tree farm from Grandpa through a six-year installment agreement.
Dad laughed.
He actually laughed with a mouthful of ham.
“He’s taking your money, son,” he said. “And you’re calling it buying.”
“It’s a contract, Dad. His lawyer drew it up.”
“I’m sure he did.”
Dad turned toward Mom with an amused expression, as though I’d just told the funniest joke he’d heard all year.
“My father is charging this boy rent to live up there and work his trees for free, and Mike thinks he’s buying the place.”
Tabitha found that absolutely hilarious.
Over the next six years, every time I saw her, she’d ask, “How’s your landlord doing?”
Dad got into the habit of writing little remarks in his Christmas cards.
Tell Dad I said hello. Hope he hasn’t raised your rent.
I corrected them the first few times. I explained the contract, the payments, and what would happen at the end of the six years. I told them it was a sale, not a rental arrangement.
They never listened long enough to understand.
Eventually, I decided they could laugh as much as they wanted.
Grandpa knew what the agreement was. Mr. Ensley knew. The bank knew.
And on the memo line of every single one of the seventy-two checks I wrote to Grandpa, I wrote the same word.
Farm.
Grandpa liked seeing it when he opened his bank statements. He said it reminded him that the place was going to stay in the family, with somebody who understood what it took to keep those trees growing.
Those six years turned out to be the hardest work I’d ever done.
They were also the best years of my life.
A Fraser fir takes eight to ten years to grow from a seedling into a Christmas tree somebody will pay good money for. During every one of those years, it needs something from you.
You plant in the spring, when the ground is soft enough to work. You mow between the rows all summer, keeping the grass and weeds from crowding out the younger trees. In July and August, when the mountain heat settles over the hillside, you trim each tree by hand, cutting back the new growth so it develops that full, even, cone-shaped appearance people expect when they come shopping for Christmas.
You do it with sweat soaking through your shirt and sticky sap covering your arms. By the end of the day, the smell of fir follows you into the house, and no amount of soap seems to get it completely off your hands.
In the fall, you begin cutting, shaking, baling, and loading trees for the wholesale lots down in Charlotte. Then, on the weekend after Thanksgiving, you open the gate and let families come onto the property to choose and cut their own trees.
That’s when the whole hillside comes alive.
People drive up from all over. Young families arrive with little kids bundled into winter coats and snow boots, some of them seeing a real Christmas tree farm for the first time. Older couples return year after year, including a few who have been coming since before I was born.
April handles the register and the wreath table, just like Grandma used to. She keeps everything organized, remembers who ordered what, and somehow manages to make the busiest day of the year look manageable.
May, who’s nine now, helps hand out the saws. She’s serious about the job and likes to make sure people understand what they’re supposed to do.
Jude is six and has appointed himself our official Christmas tree expert. He walks around telling customers which trees are good, and whenever anybody asks him for a recommendation, he gives the same answer.
“All of them.”
We have a tradition on opening day that goes all the way back to the first Christmas tree Grandpa ever sold.
The first tree of every season gets a strip of red ribbon tied near its top before it’s loaded onto the customer’s vehicle.
Grandpa always said the first tree was for good luck.
He never explained exactly what kind of luck it was supposed to bring, or whether the luck belonged to the tree, the buyer, or the farm itself. He just tied that ribbon on every year, and nobody ever thought to question it.
For as long as I can remember, the first car in line on opening morning has belonged to Mr. Ensley.
He arrives at seven-thirty in the same brown station wagon, carrying a thermos of coffee, and waits patiently for the gate to open.
He once told me he’d taken home the first Christmas tree sold from that hillside every year since 1979, and he had absolutely no intention of breaking that streak before somebody put him in the ground.
That was my life for six years.
I got out of bed at five in the morning and came home after dark. I worked through heat, rain, mud, and freezing mornings, keeping track of every tree and every dollar. There was sap on my work gloves, my truck seats, the door handles, and just about everything else I owned.
Dad still came up once a year for his free Christmas tree.
And every year, I gave him the best one I could find, because Grandpa had always done it that way. It seemed like the kind of thing a son ought to do for his father, even if that father had never spent a summer helping him grow it.
In January of the final year, I wrote check number seventy-two.
I could have mailed it like all the others, but I wanted to deliver that one myself. I drove down to Grandpa’s little house in town and handed it to him across the kitchen table.
He was eighty-six by then. His hands shook a little when he held the check, and he took his time looking at the writing.
His eyes rested on the memo line for a long while.
“Farm,” he read aloud.
Then he folded the check, tucked it into his shirt pocket, and looked up at me.
“Well,” he said, “that’s that.”
He didn’t make a speech. Grandpa wasn’t a man who needed to turn every important occasion into one. But I knew what that moment meant to him, and he knew what it meant to me.
In February, we went back to Mr. Ensley’s office.
Grandpa signed the deed transferring the property into my name, with April witnessing the transaction and Mr. Ensley completing the notarization. After everything was signed, Mr. Ensley walked across the street to the county Register of Deeds and made sure the transfer was officially recorded that same afternoon.
My name was now attached to that entire hillside.
The farmhouse, the barn, the parking lot, the rows of Fraser firs, and all twenty-two acres belonged to me.
On the courthouse steps, Grandpa handed me the recorded copy.
“Now the trees know who to listen to,” he said.
That was the last important thing he ever gave me.
Grandpa died in March.
He passed away in his sleep at the little house in town. A neighbor found him after noticing that he hadn’t come outside to collect his newspaper.
We buried him in the church cemetery beside Grandma Belma. May picked out a small Fraser fir wreath for the grave, and we laid it against the headstone.
I remember standing there looking at the two names together, thinking about how much of that hillside existed because of the work those two people had put into it. Grandpa had spent most of his life raising trees, and Grandma had spent hers helping him turn those trees into something families would take home and remember.
His will was short and uncomplicated.
He left everything he owned to his only son, Reggie.
That meant his house in town, his savings account, and his old furniture. Those were the things that still belonged to him when he died.
The Christmas tree farm wasn’t part of the estate.
It couldn’t be, because the farm had already been sold, paid for, transferred, and recorded in my name a month earlier.
Mr. Ensley offered to handle the estate for Dad, but Dad refused.
“I’m not paying some lawyer to tell me what’s already mine,” he told him.
Instead, Dad went down to the clerk’s office with a form he’d printed from his computer and handled the paperwork himself.
Grandpa’s remaining estate was small enough that the clerk allowed him to use the simpler process. Nobody at that counter had any reason to search the ownership records for a Christmas tree farm that wasn’t even mentioned in the will.
I found out later that Grandpa’s savings account contained about $61,000 when Dad inherited it.
Grandpa had used some of my payments to pay for the house in town and cover medical bills over the years. But a substantial amount had stayed in that account, untouched.
When Dad received the bank statements, he saw the deposits Grandpa had been getting every month for six years.
Each one had the same description.
Farm.
And because Dad had spent those six years laughing at the idea that I was actually buying the place, he decided those deposits were rent payments.
In his mind, Grandpa had been collecting money from me for six years and keeping it away from his own son.
Dad never bothered checking the sale records. He never called Mr. Ensley to ask about the agreement. He simply accepted the explanation he’d invented years earlier, because it was the one he wanted to believe.
In April, he wrote Tabitha a check for $20,000 from Grandpa’s account.
He called it an advance on her share of the inheritance.
Tabitha immediately bought a television about the size of a garage door and made a down payment on a Ford Explorer.
I knew nothing about that at the time.
What I knew was what I could see, and some of those things started bothering me almost immediately.
At the lunch after Grandpa’s funeral, held in the church fellowship hall, I overheard Dad speaking to my aunt Reeva.
“Michael will keep running the farm for me for now,” he told her, “until we figure out what we’re going to do with it.”
I walked over to them.
“Dad, I bought the farm. You know it’s paid off.”
He looked at me with that patient, condescending expression he used whenever he thought I was being foolish.
“You were renting it,” he said.
Then he patted my shoulder as though I were a little boy who’d said something amusing.
“We’ll talk about this later. Not today.”
We never did talk about it later.
I called him twice in April to straighten things out. Both times, he said he was busy and would call me back.
He never did.
Then, one Saturday in July, Dad and Tabitha drove up to the farm without calling ahead.
I was working on the north slope, pruning trees with sap all over my hands and forearms. When I looked up, I saw the two of them walking between the rows, studying the hillside as if they were taking measurements for new carpeting.
Tabitha had her phone out, photographing the view from the top of the hill.
Dad found me near the barn, where I was putting in another row of seedlings.
He watched for a moment before telling me I could stop planting.
“We won’t be here long enough for those things to grow,” he said.
I straightened up and looked at him.
“I’m going to keep planting. And next time, call before you come up. This isn’t a public park.”
Tabitha laughed.
“He’s gotten attached, Dad. Isn’t that cute?”
I pulled off my gloves.
“I’m not attached. I’m the owner.”
Neither of them answered.
“You want to see the deed?” I asked. “It’s in the house. Come on inside and take a look.”
Dad was already turning toward his car.
“I’ve seen the will,” he called over his shoulder. “That’s all I need to see.”
I didn’t chase him down the hill.
A man who won’t walk twenty yards to look at a deed isn’t going to read it just because you shove it in front of his face. The truth was sitting in the courthouse records in Jefferson, where anybody in the world could go and look at it.
I had told him where to find it. I had offered to put it directly in his hands.
If he didn’t want to know, I couldn’t make him want to know.
The next few months passed with the usual work. I kept mowing, pruning, and preparing for the Christmas season. There were wholesale orders to fill, equipment to check, and hundreds of trees that needed to be ready before Thanksgiving.
Then, the week before Thanksgiving, a text message came in from Tabitha.
Dad and I have a buyer for Grandpa’s farm. His name is Pierce Lunsford. He’s in the cabin rental business. He wants to come see the property the day after Thanksgiving. Please have the place cleaned up. No sap everywhere.
I stared at the screen.
The day after Thanksgiving.
Opening day.
The busiest morning of my entire year, when I would have sixty cars trying to get into the parking lot and families lined up to choose their Christmas trees.
I wrote back.
It isn’t yours to sell. Call the courthouse.
Dad responded before Tabitha did.
Grandpa’s will says everything belongs to me. You’re the employee, son. Be polite on Friday.
I called him.
The phone rang until the call ended.
I called again and went straight to voicemail.
So I sat down at my computer and searched for Lunsford Cabin Rentals.
It was a real company based in Boone, with roughly forty rental cabins scattered across the mountain region. I found the office number and called.
A recorded message informed me that the office was closed for the Thanksgiving holiday and that calls would be returned on Monday.
I left a message anyway.
“Mr. Lunsford, my name is Mike. I understand you’re scheduled to look at the Christmas tree farm outside West Jefferson this Friday. Before you go any further with my father, please call me. That farm is not for sale, and it does not belong to him.”
Then I hung up and went back to work.
I had four hundred trees to bale for Charlotte before Wednesday, and nobody was going to do that work for me.
By Wednesday evening, April was beginning to worry about Thanksgiving.
We were sitting in the kitchen when she asked whether we should skip dinner at my parents’ house.
“If we don’t go, they’ll say I’m hiding,” I told her. “I’m not hiding anything, and I have nothing to hide. We’ll go. We’ll eat. And if they bring up the farm, I’ll tell them the truth again.”
I thought about it for a moment.
“Maybe a little slower this time.”
April didn’t look particularly convinced, but she didn’t argue.
So on Thursday around noon, we drove down the mountain to Hickory with May and Jude in the back seat and a pecan pie resting in April’s lap.
My mother’s name is Caroline.
She’s a good woman who has never once, in her entire life, openly disagreed with my father when other people were around. She has always been the one who smooths things over, changes the subject, and tries to make everybody comfortable.
She met us at the door, hugged the kids, took the pie from April, and told me I looked tired.
She was right.
There were fourteen of us gathered for Thanksgiving dinner. Mom and Dad, Tabitha, Aunt Reeva and her husband, two cousins with their children, and the four of us.
Mom had made both turkey and ham because Aunt Reeva doesn’t like turkey. The table was crowded with serving dishes, and for a while, the afternoon felt almost normal.
Nobody said a single word about the farm through the entire meal.
I started thinking that maybe we’d get through the day without a fight.
Maybe Dad had finally called the courthouse. Maybe he’d seen the recorded deed and was too embarrassed to admit he’d been wrong in front of everyone.
I let myself believe that for almost an hour.
Then Mom brought out the pies.
Tabitha put down her fork and smiled.
“Well,” she said, “we have some big news.”
I knew from the way she said it that the afternoon was about to go bad.
“Pierce Lunsford is offering three hundred and ninety thousand dollars for Grandpa’s farm.”
Aunt Reeva looked up.
“Well, my goodness.”
“He wants to build cabins,” Tabitha continued, looking around the table like she’d just won a contest. “Ten of them, right along the top of the hill where you can see the mountains. He’s coming up tomorrow to walk the property. Dad and I are meeting him at eight.”
“We’re not selling,” I said.
Tabitha turned toward me.
“We weren’t asking you.”
“It isn’t yours to sell. I told you that last week. I told Dad in July. I told him at the funeral. That farm doesn’t belong to you, and it doesn’t belong to him.”
Dad wiped his mouth with his napkin.
“Your grandfather left me everything, son. It’s in the will. Everything.”
“Grandpa left you everything he owned when he died,” I said. “But he didn’t own the farm when he died. I did.”
“He was renting you that farm,” Dad said, raising his voice.
He leaned forward, and I could see that he wasn’t merely confused. He was angry about something he’d been carrying around in his head for months.
“He collected that rent for six years and never shared a single penny with his own son. I saw the bank statements. Farm, fourteen hundred dollars, every month. Well, now we’re selling the place. Your sister and I are splitting the money, and that makes up for every one of those six years.”
I looked at him.
“Dad, those checks were payments for the farm. That’s why they said ‘Farm.’”
“Rent would say ‘Farm,’ too,” Tabitha interrupted.
One of my cousins laughed.
That was when Dad stood up and tapped his iced tea glass with his fork.
The sound cut through the conversation, and everybody at the table went quiet.
“The children need to go watch television,” he announced.
Then he reached into his shirt pocket and pulled out a folded letter.
Two typewritten pages. He didn’t own a printer, so he had gone to the library to print them. He had done all of that before Thanksgiving dinner, before I had even walked through the door.
April recognized what was happening immediately.
She got up and took May and Jude toward the front door instead of sending them into the living room.
Jude asked if he could take his pie with him.
She let him.
Across the table, Tabitha rotated her phone sideways and pressed the record button. She followed April and the children with the camera as they walked away.
I reached across and covered the lens with my hand.
“Not them.”
Tabitha pulled the phone back and aimed it directly at me. She leaned over the table until my face filled the little screen.
Dad unfolded the letter.
“I wrote this last night,” he told the room, “because I knew he’d act like this.”
Then he began reading.
“Mike, as the executor of my father’s estate and as his only son, I have tried to be patient with you. For six years, you have lived in my father’s house, worked my father’s land, and paid him rent like a tenant while he kept that money hidden from his own family.”
He glanced up at me, then continued.
“You turned my father against me. I said nothing while he was alive out of respect for him, but now he’s gone. The farm is mine, and I will decide what happens to it.”
Mom shifted in her chair.
“Reggie,” she said quietly. “Not at the table.”
He ignored her.
“Your sister has found a good buyer. You have refused to cooperate. So I’m telling you this in front of the entire family. As of today, I have only one child.”
Nobody spoke.
Dad kept reading.
“You may stay in the farmhouse until Christmas for the sake of the children. After that, you will leave that land, and you will never set foot on Grandpa’s Christmas tree farm again.”
He placed the second page on top of the first and held the letter out to me.
Mom was looking at me with tears in her eyes.
“Just take it, honey,” she said. “He’s upset.”
Tabitha’s phone was about eight inches from my nose.
I could see myself in the little screen. I looked exhausted, and there was a crumb of pie crust stuck to my chin.
I brushed it away.
Then I took Dad’s letter, folded it in half, folded it in half again, and slipped it into the inside pocket of my coat.
“Deal,” I said. “Neither will you.”
Dad’s face tightened.
“What is that supposed to mean?”
“It means exactly what it says, Dad. You wrote it.”
I pushed my chair back into place and stood.
“Thanks for dinner, Mom. The ham was really good.”
Aunt Reeva reached toward me.
“Mike, honey, sit down.”
“Not today, Reeva.”
I walked out to the car.
May was buckled into the back seat with her arms crossed tightly over her chest. Jude was sitting beside her, eating his pie with his fingers.
“Is Grandpa mad at Daddy?” Jude asked.
I looked at him in the rearview mirror.
“Grandpa made a mistake,” I said. “He just doesn’t know it yet.”
April didn’t say anything until we had been driving for a while.
Then she turned toward me.
“What’s he going to do tomorrow?”
“He’s going to bring a buyer onto our property on the busiest day of our year.”
“And what are you going to do?”
“I’m going to make sure that buyer talks to the man who actually owns it.”
By nine that night, Tabitha had uploaded the video to Facebook.
She captioned it:
Sometimes you have to choose family. My brother chose the trees.
She had edited out the beginning of the argument, all the explanations about the deed, and everything that had happened before Dad started reading.
The video began with Dad’s voice saying, “As of today, I have only one child.”
It ended with me looking straight at him and saying, “Neither will you.”
Then Tabitha’s own voice could be heard from behind the camera.
“Wow. Okay.”
By ten o’clock, half our cousins had shared it. Two of Mom’s friends from church had shared it, too. People I hadn’t spoken to in years were leaving comments about praying for our family.
I found that particularly ironic, considering I was the only person at the Thanksgiving table who hadn’t been trying to sell something that didn’t belong to him.
Aunt Reeva called at ten-thirty.
“Honey, I’m not taking sides,” she began.
That was what people in my family usually said right before explaining the side they’d already taken.
“But your father is beside himself. Can’t the two of you just come to some kind of agreement?”
“Reeva, can I ask you something?”
“Of course.”
“Who do you think owns that farm?”
She hesitated.
“Well, your father. Grandpa left him everything.”
“Come up Saturday,” I told her. “Buy a Christmas tree. I’ll show you something, and then you can decide who has lost his mind.”
She was quiet for a moment.
“All right,” she said. “I’ll come up.”
After I hung up, I sat down at the old red kitchen table.
April settled into the chair across from me with her cup of tea.
I took Dad’s letter out of my coat and smoothed it flat on the tabletop. Then I walked into the front room, opened the desk, and took out the folder Mr. Ensley had given me in February.
Inside was the recorded deed, complete with the Register of Deeds stamp, the February 12 recording date, and Grandpa’s signature at the bottom.
His handwriting was a little shaky, but the signature was unmistakable.
Behind it was a copy of our original purchase contract, with Mr. Ensley’s written note clipped to the front, along with bank records showing all seventy-two payments.
Six years of checks.
Six years of work.
Everything Dad had refused to believe was right there in one folder.
I put the deed in my left inside coat pocket and Dad’s letter in my right.
Then I picked up my phone and sent him a text.
Bring Pierce at eight. I’ll have the paperwork ready.
He replied about thirty seconds later.
Good. I’m glad you’ve finally come to your senses. Be out before New Year’s.
April read the message over my shoulder.
“He thinks you’re going to hand him the keys.”
“I told him I’d have the paperwork ready.”
She looked at me for a long moment, then set her cup down.
“Mike, it’s cruel to do it this way.”
I thought about that.
I really did, because I didn’t want to be cruel. I didn’t want to become the kind of man who needed to humiliate somebody just to prove he could.
But I kept seeing Dad standing at that Thanksgiving table, holding his letter like a judge delivering a sentence.
“He stood up in front of fourteen people, including our children, and told me I wasn’t his son anymore,” I said. “Over a farm he hasn’t worked a single day of his adult life.”
April listened without interrupting.
“That deed has been available at the courthouse since February. I’ve spent nine months telling him it’s mine. Tomorrow he’s bringing a stranger onto our land to sell it out from under us and our children.”
I looked down at the folder.
“I’m not going to embarrass him in front of everybody. I’ll take him aside and show him one piece of paper. He can read it or refuse to read it, but this time he’s going to hold it in his own hands.”
April took another sip of tea.
“Off to the side,” she said. “By the barn. Not in front of the line.”
“By the barn,” I agreed.
“Then I’ll handle the register, and you handle your father.”
That was April. Even when the whole family was falling apart, she was thinking about how to keep the business running.
Afterward, I called my two part-time employees.
Sub was seventy-three and had been helping with opening weekend since Grandpa was a younger man. He called everybody “son,” including April, and had been around long enough to know most of the strange habits in my family.
Kelton was sixteen, a local kid who could bale Christmas trees faster than anybody else in Ashe County. At least, that was what Kelton claimed, and he was always happy to explain exactly how fast he was.
I told them both to be at the farm at seven sharp.
“There might be a little family business to deal with in the morning,” I said.
“What kind of family business?” Sub asked.
“The kind where you keep the line moving and don’t stand around watching.”
He didn’t miss a beat.
“Son, I’ve been not watching your family since 1980.”
I couldn’t help smiling at that.
Then I put the phone down, checked the folder one more time, and got everything ready for morning.
The morning after Thanksgiving, the temperature on the hillside was twenty-eight degrees Fahrenheit.
Frost covered every tree, turning the rows of dark green Fraser firs silver in the early light. The gravel crunched under my boots, and every breath came out in a little cloud.
Cars started lining up at the entrance around seven-fifteen. By the time I opened the gate, the line stretched past the mailbox and around the bend in the road.
At seven-thirty, right on schedule, the familiar brown station wagon rolled up to the front.
Mr. Ensley lowered his window with his thermos of coffee in one hand.
“Morning, Mike. You look like a man who didn’t sleep.”
“Morning, Mr. Ensley. I didn’t.”
He nodded as though he’d already expected that answer.
“Saw a video last night,” he said. “My granddaughter showed it to me. Your sister is quite the camera operator.”
I looked at him.
“You saw it?”
“Half of Ashe County saw it, son.”
He took a sip of coffee and glanced toward the rows of trees.
“Any chance your father’s coming up here this morning with a buyer?”
“Eight o’clock.”
Mr. Ensley nodded slowly, as casually as if I’d just told him the weather forecast.
“Well,” he said, “I believe I’ll take my time picking out my tree this year.”
Then he drove into the parking lot.
Exactly at eight, Dad’s Buick came up the driveway with Tabitha in the passenger seat.
Behind him was a large black pickup truck with Lunsford Cabin Rentals painted in small letters on the door.
The parking lot was already full enough that they had to leave their vehicles near the mailbox and walk up the gravel drive. They passed at least forty families carrying saws, holding children’s hands, and studying the rows of trees.
Dad walked uphill as though everything around him belonged to him. He waved at a few people along the way, smiling like the owner of a business greeting customers.
Tabitha already had her phone out, filming the scenery.
The man from the black truck looked to be in his fifties. He wore an expensive-looking canvas jacket that didn’t appear to have ever brushed against a Christmas tree, much less been worn while working among them.
I met the three of them at the edge of the parking lot.
“Let’s talk over here,” I said, pointing toward the barn. “Out of everybody’s way.”
Dad frowned.
“We can talk right here.”
“I’ve got customers, Dad. By the barn.”
He looked irritated, but he followed.
We walked around the side of the barn near the tree shaker, where the noise of the parking lot faded enough for us to hear one another. The steady movement of people and cars continued on the other side of the building. Every now and then, I could hear Sub calling for the next customer.
Standing there were Dad, Tabitha, Pierce Lunsford, and me.
Before anybody else said anything, Pierce held up his phone.
“Are you Mike?”
“Yes, sir.”
He looked a little pale.
“You left me a voicemail Tuesday.”
“I did.”
“I didn’t listen to it until I was sitting in your driveway about ten minutes ago.”
Dad turned toward him.
“What voicemail?”
Pierce looked directly at my father.
“He told me the farm isn’t for sale. He also said it doesn’t belong to you.”
Dad laughed, but there wasn’t much confidence in it.
“He’s been saying that for months. It’s the will, Pierce. My father left me everything. I’m the executor. This is all mine.”
Tabitha shifted her weight and looked at me.
“Well, where are those papers you said you’d have ready?”
She raised her phone again.
“Put it away, Tabitha,” I said.
She didn’t move.
“Put it away, or I’m done talking. All three of you can go home and keep wondering what the truth is.”
She glanced at Dad.
He gave a small nod, and she slipped the phone into her coat pocket.
I reached into my left inside pocket, pulled out the folder, and took out the recorded deed.
Then I handed it to Pierce.
Not Dad.
Pierce.
He was the man who’d been lied to, and he was the man who needed to know the truth before any more money changed hands.
Pierce opened the document and read it carefully.
Then he went back to the beginning and read it a second time.
A man who makes his living buying land knows exactly what a recorded deed looks like. He knows where to find the grantor, the grantee, the recording information, and the signatures. He doesn’t need somebody explaining the difference between a will and a property transfer.
“Recorded February twelfth,” he said, reading from the page. “Grantor, Ulten. Grantee, Mike.”
He looked up at Dad.
“Reggie, this says your father sold this farm to your son and transferred the deed a month before he died.”
Dad shook his head.
“That’s not possible.”
Pierce looked back at the paper.
“He was paying rent,” Dad insisted.
“He was paying for the farm.”
That wasn’t my voice.
Mr. Ensley had come around the corner of the barn, carrying his thermos in one hand.
He’d been practicing law for fifty-one years, and he walked toward us with the calm expression of a man who had been expecting this particular conversation since February.
“Morning, Reggie,” he said.
Dad turned.
“Mr. Ensley.”
“I drew up that sales contract myself six years ago, in my office in Jefferson.”
He stepped beside Pierce and glanced at the deed.
“Your father sat across my desk and told me exactly what he wanted. I asked him every question I was required to ask, and then some. I made a note in my file that he was as sharp as any man I’d ever known, because I had a feeling somebody might come asking about it one day.”
Dad didn’t say anything.
Mr. Ensley continued.
“Fourteen hundred dollars a month for six years. Your boy paid every month on time. Seventy-two checks. Paid it off in January.”
He tapped the document in Pierce’s hand.
“Your father signed the deed in February. Mike’s wife was there, and I handled the notarization. I walked it across the street and had it recorded myself.”
He paused to take a sip of coffee.
“I also offered to help you with your father’s estate, Reggie. You told me you weren’t going to pay a lawyer to tell you what was already yours.”
Mr. Ensley lowered his thermos.
“Well, Reggie, I’m telling you for free. This farm isn’t yours.”
Dad stared at the deed.
His mouth opened slightly, then closed again. He looked from Pierce to Mr. Ensley and back to the paper, as though the words might change if he gave them enough time.
Tabitha was the first to find her voice.
“Then where’s the money?”
She looked at me.
“If he paid a hundred thousand dollars for the farm, where did it go?”
I turned toward her, then looked at Dad.
“Where do you think it went, Tabitha?”
She didn’t answer.
“Grandpa put it in his bank account. Who inherited Grandpa’s bank account?”
Nobody spoke.
Behind the barn wall, the tree baler started up with its familiar mechanical rumble, ran for a few seconds, and stopped again.
“Farm,” I said. “Fourteen hundred dollars every month. You said it yourself at dinner, Dad. You saw those deposits on his bank statements.”
Dad’s face had gone pale.
“My father owed me that money,” he said. “He kept it from me for six years.”
“No, Dad. He left you what remained in that account, and you’ve already spent it.”
I looked him in the eyes.
“You’ve already been paid for the farm. Do you know who paid you?”
He said nothing.
“I did.”
Tabitha took a step backward, like the ground had shifted beneath her feet.
For six years, she and Dad had treated me like some foolish tenant working for free on a property I’d never own.
They had mocked my monthly payments, ignored the contract, refused to look at the deed, and convinced themselves that Grandpa’s savings belonged to them because the farm was supposed to belong to them.
Now they were standing on land they had never owned, looking at proof that they had already benefited financially from the sale they spent six years denying had happened.
I let that settle for a moment.
Then I reached into my right inside pocket.
I took out Dad’s letter.
I unfolded it carefully, the same way he’d unfolded it in front of the family the afternoon before.
Then I read the last line on the second page.
“After that, you will leave that land, and you will never set foot on Grandpa’s Christmas tree farm again.”
I folded it again.
“This isn’t Grandpa’s Christmas tree farm anymore, Dad. It’s mine.”
Dad looked at me, his jaw tightening.
“But I’m going to hold you to every word of this,” I continued. “You wrote it. You read it out loud. Tabitha put it on Facebook.”
I put the letter back into my pocket.
“So you’re going to walk back down to your car, and you’re not coming up this hill again. Not for a free Christmas tree. Not for anything.”
Dad’s expression hardened.
“You can’t keep me off my own father’s land.”
“It’s not your father’s land. You just saw the deed. That’s the whole point.”
Pierce cleared his throat.
He’d been watching Dad with the increasingly uncomfortable expression of a man trying to remember exactly where he’d parked his truck and whether he could leave without getting dragged any deeper into somebody else’s family argument.
“Reggie,” he said, “there’s another matter we need to discuss.”
Dad turned toward him.
“Two weeks ago, I wrote you a check to hold this property while we got the paperwork ready.”
I looked at Pierce.
That was the first I’d heard about any money changing hands.
He kept his attention on Dad.
“I’m going to need that money returned by Monday, if you don’t mind.”
Dad slowly turned toward Tabitha.
Her face went red, all the way to her hairline.
“I, uh, paid my credit card with it.”
Dad stared at her.
“You did what?”
“You endorsed the check to me, Dad. You told me to hold onto it.”
“To hold onto it. Not spend it.”
Pierce raised both hands.
“Folks, I don’t care which one of you had the money. I care that it’s back in my account by Monday.”
He didn’t raise his voice. He didn’t threaten anybody. He spoke with the flat certainty of a businessman who had just discovered a deal was considerably more complicated than he’d been led to believe.
Then he handed the deed back to me.
Not to Dad.
To me.
And he did something I wasn’t expecting.
He extended his hand.
“Pierce Lunsford,” he said.
I shook it.
“Mike.”
“I’m sorry about all this. I should have checked my messages before coming out here.”
He glanced at Dad, then turned his attention back to me.
“A man who pays his grandfather for six years, even at a family price, instead of taking the land and running with the money? I’d rather do business with a man like that than just about anybody else on this mountain.”
I wasn’t sure what to say.
Pierce continued.
“I’ve got forty cabins in this county. Every one of them needs a Christmas tree and a wreath in December. My supplier down in Boone let me down last year.”
He looked toward the rows beyond the barn.
“You do wholesale?”
“Yes, sir.”
“Mind if I give you a call to talk about it?”
“Call me Monday,” I said. “Right now, I’ve got a whole line of people waiting to buy trees.”
He laughed.
“Fair enough.”
Pierce looked at Dad and Tabitha one last time, shook his head, and started walking back down the gravel driveway toward his black truck.
Alone.
Dad remained standing beside the barn.
For the first time that morning, he had nothing in his hands. No will, no letter, no paperwork, and no buyer willing to listen to him.
Tabitha’s phone stayed in her pocket.
“Mike,” Dad began.
I cut him off.
“Kelton will walk you down.”
I turned toward the barn.
“Kelton!”
He appeared around the corner with a saw resting across his shoulder.
“Yes, boss?”
“Would you walk my father and my sister back down to their car, please? Then go help that family in the green coats. They’ve been staring at the same tree for twenty minutes.”
“Yes, boss.”
Kelton turned toward Dad.
“Sir, it’s this way.”
Dad stood there for another moment.
Then he started walking.
He didn’t look back.
Tabitha followed him, and she didn’t look back, either.
The families waiting in line moved aside to let them pass, barely paying any attention. They were too busy studying the trees, helping their kids carry saws, and deciding which Fraser fir would look best in their living rooms.
For them, it was just another happy Friday morning at the Christmas tree farm.
For me, it was the morning my father finally found out he’d spent nine months trying to sell something that had never belonged to him.
Mr. Ensley stayed beside me, watching Dad and Tabitha disappear down the hill.
“Fifty-one years,” he said.
I looked at him.
“I’ve read a lot of deeds out loud in fifty-one years. But I believe that’s one of the few times I actually enjoyed doing it.”
He took another sip from his thermos, then turned toward the rows.
“Now, is the first tree of the season still mine, or did your father take that, too?”
I laughed for the first time all morning.
“It’s yours, Mr. Ensley. Go pick one out.”
He chose a seven-foot Fraser fir in the third row, one of the fullest trees on the whole hillside.
I cut it myself. Kelton carried it to the shaker, cleaned it, and ran it through the baler.
Then May came running over from the wreath table with a roll of red ribbon in her hands.
She’d been waiting all morning.
I’d told her that tying the ribbon on the first tree of the season would be her job that year, and she had taken the responsibility seriously.
She carefully wrapped a strip of ribbon near the top of Mr. Ensley’s tree and tied it with a double knot.
He paid for the tree in cash, the exact amount, and had her count the money to make sure she’d gotten it right.
May looked at the ribbon and smiled.
“The first one’s for good luck,” she said.
Mr. Ensley smiled back at her.
“Your great-grandfather told me that same thing in 1979,” he said. “And I’ve had a fair amount of good luck since then.”
We sold 312 trees that weekend.
It was the best opening weekend that hillside had ever seen.
Aunt Reeva came up on Saturday, just like she’d promised.
April made coffee, and I sat down with her at the old red kitchen table. I took out the deed and laid it in front of her.
She put on her reading glasses and went through the document carefully.
Then she read it again.
When she finished, she took off her glasses, slipped them into her pocket, and sat there for a moment.
“Well,” she said, “that video is going to look a whole lot different by tonight.”
She bought a six-foot Christmas tree and two wreaths.
I offered her a discount.
She refused.
She paid the full price and wouldn’t let me argue about it.
By Saturday evening, Tabitha had deleted her Facebook video. Unfortunately for her, about forty relatives had already watched it, and Aunt Reeva had apparently made it her personal mission to call every single one of them.
Reeva doesn’t use Facebook.
She’s never needed it.
By Sunday, half my cousins had sent me messages saying they had no idea about the sale agreement, the deed, or anything else that had actually happened.
The other half suddenly went very quiet.
That was its own kind of message.
Dad returned Pierce’s deposit on Monday.
He had to sell his fishing boat to do it.
It turned out he’d bought the boat brand-new in May with some of the money left in Grandpa’s savings account. So, in a manner of speaking, the payments I’d made for my farm had been floating around on Lake Hickory all summer.
Dad had to sell the boat at a loss.
I learned that from Mom.
Then Dad turned around and told Tabitha she owed him every cent of the $20,000 he’d given her as an advance on her inheritance.
The inheritance she had expected from selling the farm wasn’t coming, and the money she’d already spent was suddenly a problem.
Tabitha returned the enormous television.
She traded the Explorer back to the dealership and lost her down payment.
She spent Christmas in her apartment, even though she’d been planning a beach vacation funded by her share of the farm money.
It turned out there was no share of the farm money.
There never had been.
Dad called me in the middle of December.
It was the first time he’d called me since Grandpa’s funeral.
“Your mother wants a tree,” he said.
His voice sounded almost normal, as though we were about to have the same conversation we’d had every December for years.
“I’ll come up Saturday, like always.”
I was standing in the farmhouse kitchen when he said it.
“Read your letter, Dad.”
Silence.
“The last line,” I added.
He didn’t say anything for a long time.
Then he cleared his throat.
“I could take that part of the letter back.”
I looked out the window toward the trees.
“You read it out loud in front of fourteen people, including our kids. Tabitha put it on the internet. You don’t get to take that back just because it turned out you were wrong.”
He breathed into the phone.
“I’m not angry with you, Dad,” I said. “I’m just holding you to your word, because that’s what Grandpa taught me a man is supposed to do.”
He hung up.
That Saturday, Mom came up by herself.
Dad’s letter hadn’t said anything about her, and I wasn’t about to punish her for words she hadn’t written.
She drove the Buick up the mountain alone, something she hadn’t done in about twenty years.
She picked out a six-foot Fraser fir and paid full price for it.
Like Aunt Reeva, she wouldn’t accept a discount.
Afterward, she went looking for May and Jude at the wreath table.
I saw her kneel down on the gravel in her good coat so she could look them in the eyes.
She told them she was sorry about what had happened at Thanksgiving.
Then she told them their daddy hadn’t done anything wrong.
May studied her for a long moment.
“Okay,” she finally said.
Then she turned her attention back to the wreaths.
Jude asked Grandma if she wanted to see the good trees.
She said she would love to.
So he took her around and showed her every single one.
I watched them from a distance, my mother following a six-year-old boy between the rows while he explained why every tree on the hillside was worth buying.
When she finally came back toward the parking lot, she stopped beside me.
“Your father is a stubborn man, Mike.”
“So am I, Mom.”
She looked at me.
“I must have gotten it from somewhere.”
She gave a small nod.
Then she got into the Buick and drove back down the mountain.
She didn’t ask me to make things right with Dad.
I think she knew I wasn’t going to.
In January, Pierce Lunsford called me, just as he’d promised.
We met at his office in Boone and worked out the details of a wholesale arrangement. When we’d agreed on everything, we shook hands.
Each December, during the first week of the month, I supply a Christmas tree and a wreath for each of his forty rental cabins.
It’s the biggest regular customer the farm has ever had.
The business is worth more than Grandpa ever made in a year from his wholesale Christmas tree lots down in Charlotte.
Pierce says the people staying in his cabins have even started mentioning the Christmas trees in their reviews.
I think Grandpa would have liked that.
He always believed a good tree could make a family remember a place long after they’d gone home.
That spring, April and I cleared another acre on the north slope near the top of the hill.
It was the exact stretch of land where Tabitha had said Pierce wanted to build his ten vacation cabins to take advantage of the mountain view.
Instead of clearing it for roads, foundations, and rental properties, we prepared the soil for more Fraser firs.
Then we planted two thousand seedlings by hand.
Row after row, one small tree at a time.
May and Jude planted the first two.
Jude immediately gave his tree a name.
May told him he wasn’t supposed to name Christmas trees.
“They’re going to get sold,” she explained.
Jude looked at his little seedling and thought about that.
Then he announced that he’d buy his own tree when it was big enough.
Those seedlings will be ready in about eight years.
May will be seventeen.
Jude will be fourteen, and I have a feeling he’ll still be insisting that every Christmas tree on the farm is a good one.
I’ll be right here on this hillside, trimming those trees in the summer heat with sap covering my arms, just like I have been doing for most of my life.
The farmhouse will still be standing where Grandpa built it in 1968. The barn will still have its shaker and baler, and the gravel lot will still fill up every Thanksgiving weekend with families who don’t know how to park properly.
April will be running the register, and the first tree of the season will still get its strip of red ribbon.
And somewhere in those new rows on the north slope, Jude’s little tree will keep growing until the day he decides whether he’s really going to buy it.
My name is already on the only piece of paper that matters.
It’s recorded at the courthouse in Jefferson, where anybody who wants to know the truth can go and look it up.
Grandpa told me the trees would know who to listen to.